zignature limited ingredient dog food review

Zignature Dog Food Review (2024)

Customer Reviews and Feedback

Customer feedback on Zignature Dog Food across various platforms presents a predominantly positive picture. Many pet owners report significant improvements in their dogs health after switching to Zignature, particularly praising the brand for its effectiveness in managing food sensitivities and allergies.

Reviews frequently highlight reductions in skin irritations, digestive problems, and other allergy-related symptoms, attributing these health improvements to Zignatures limited ingredient and hypoallergenic formulas. The variety of unique protein sources available is also a point of satisfaction, allowing owners to tailor their dogs diet to avoid common allergens effectively.

However, as with any product, not all feedback is universally positive. A minority of reviews express disappointment, noting that some dogs did not take well to the taste of certain formulas or did not show the expected health improvements. These instances underscore the individual nature of dietary needs and preferences among dogs, emphasizing the importance of finding a diet that aligns with each pets specific requirements.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Limited Ingredient Diets: Ideal for dogs with food sensitivities, allergies, or special dietary needs.
• Unique Protein Sources: Offers a range of novel proteins, reducing the likelihood of allergic reactions.
• Grain-Free Formulas: Caters to dogs with grain sensitivities and aligns with a more natural, ancestral diet.
• Nutritional Quality: High-quality ingredients ensure a balanced diet, supporting overall health and well-being.

Cons:

• Price Point: Premium pricing may be a barrier for some pet owners.
• Palatability: Some dogs may find certain formulas less appealing, posing challenges for picky eaters.
• Limited Availability: While widely available online and in specialty stores, some locations may have a limited selection.

Comparison with Competitors

Comparing Zignature Dog Food to similar premium brands such as Acana, Orijen, and The Honest Kitchen reveals both commonalities and distinctions. Like Zignature, these brands emphasize high-quality ingredients, grain-free options, and nutritional integrity.

However, Zignature sets itself apart with its unique approach to limited ingredient diets and the use of novel proteins, catering specifically to dogs with food sensitivities and allergies. In terms of pricing, Zignature is competitive within the premium segment, offering comparable value given its specialized dietary focus.

While brands like Orijen and Acana prioritize biologically appropriate diets with a broader range of ingredients, Zignatures simpler formulas can be particularly advantageous for dogs with specific health concerns. The Honest Kitchen, offering dehydrated whole foods, presents an alternative for those seeking minimally processed options, yet Zignatures dry and wet food lines provide a more conventional feeding approach with the added benefit of catering to sensitive diets.

Expert Opinions and Overall Score

Zignature Dog Food Score: 8.5/10

Veterinarians and animal nutrition experts often recommend Zignature Dog Food for pets with allergies or food sensitivities, citing its limited ingredient approach and selection of novel proteins as key factors in its effectiveness. Experts appreciate the brands commitment to quality and its avoidance of common allergens, making it a valuable option for managing diet-related health issues.

Given the specific needs it addresses, the expert consensus on Zignature is largely positive, with the brand frequently recommended for its hypoallergenic properties. However, experts also advise that pet owners consult with a veterinarian to ensure that Zignatures formulas meet the individual nutritional requirements of their dogs, particularly for those with complex health issues.

Overall, Zignature Dog Food earns a score of 8.5 out of 10 for its specialized focus on hypoallergenic diets, quality ingredients, and the positive health outcomes reported by many pet owners. This score reflects the brands success in catering to a niche market within the pet food industry, offering substantial benefits for dogs with specific dietary needs.

Conclusion

Zignature Dog Food presents a compelling option for pet owners seeking specialized nutrition solutions for their dogs, particularly those with allergies or food sensitivities. The brands commitment to limited ingredient, hypoallergenic formulas, combined with the use of high-quality and novel proteins, positions Zignature as a leader in this niche market.

While the premium price point and potential palatability issues for some dogs are considerations, the overall value offered by Zignatureevidenced by positive customer feedback and expert endorsementsmakes it a worthwhile choice for many. As with any dietary change, consultation with a veterinary professional is crucial to ensure that Zignature meets the specific nutritional needs of individual pets, optimizing the benefits of this specialized dog food brand.

Zignature Dog Food Review: How Does It Stack Up?

Zignature is a premium dog food brand that produces a number of high-quality, meat-based, limited-ingredient recipes.

Well examine the brands philosophy, corporate history, and manufacturing process below, and analyze a few of their recipes in detail, so you can pick the best one for your pet.

Zignature Quick Picks

Zignature History & Background

Zignature is made by Pets Global, Inc., an independent, holistic wellness company with a passion for animal welfare. A family owned and operated business, Pets Global, Inc. was founded in 2010, with the goal of producing recipes that provide your pet with total nutrition.

Unlike some other pet food manufacturers, which produce foods under a dozen or more brand names, Pets Global Inc. only produces two brands: Zignature Dog Foods and Fussie Cat Premium Cat Foods.

All Zignature Dog Foods are manufactured in one of two US-based facilities, one of which is located in Perham, Minnesota, and the other in Mitchell, South Dakota. All of the ingredients used in Zignature recipes are sourced from France, New Zealand, Australia, and the U.S.

Pets Global Inc. is headquartered in Valencia, California.

Zignature Customer Reception & Opinion

By and large, most dog owners who try Zignature dog foods end up being very pleased with their decision.

Most of Zignatures recipes received very good reviews on Amazon (as well as the sites of other retailers), and Dog Food Advisor rates most of the companys recipes as 4- or 5-star products (the primary difference between 4- and 5-star products was usually protein content those with higher protein content received higher ratings).

Many owners tried Zignature Dog Foods in an attempt to avoid grains, potatoes or other ingredients that sometimes cause itchy skin and other problems for some dogs. In most cases, they reported that Zignature did the trick, and helped to soothe their pups skin issues.

Additionally, most owners reported that their dog loved the taste of Zignatures various recipes.

Recall History

We werent able to find any reported recalls for Zignature Dog Foods.

Zignature Formulas & Recipes

Zignature produces both kibble and canned dog foods. Each of the brands recipes are made with high-quality meats, meat meals, and low-glycemic vegetables, and without any of the artificial ingredients that owners typically like to avoid.

In total, Zignature produces 26 different formulas, including 13 kibbles and 13 canned options. Each of the formulas in each product line are designed to be nutritionally similar so you can rotate between different formulas if you like.

Note that Zignature uses slightly different language than K9 of Mine and most other manufacturers do, as they refer to their individual products as formulas, rather than recipes. This doesnt mean anything to your dog, nor does this naming convention have any nutritional implications, but it is worth mentioning.

Formula #1: Zignature Dry Foods (Kibble)

Our Rating:

All of Zignatures dry foods feature a high-quality, whole protein at the beginning of the ingredient list. This is followed by a premium meat-meal, and then a number of low-glycemic vegetables are used to provide the carbohydrate content.

All of Zignatures kibbles are grain-free and limited-ingredient, which means that they wont include any unnecessary additives or ingredients, providing only the essential nutrients your dog needs and no mysterious extras.

While the specific ingredients used vary slightly from one formula to the next, most are broadly similar in terms of nutrition and quality.

Well use Zignatures Trout and Salmon Meal Formula as a case study for the brands dry formulas.

Percentages

The Guaranteed Analysis (the nutritional information printed on the foods label) for Zignatures Trout and Salmon Meal Formula is as follows:

• Protein 30%
• Fat 14%
• Carbohydrate Not Provided

However, it is often better to compare different dog food formulas and recipes by using a dry matter basis (the nutritional content of the food once the water is removed). This is especially important if you are comparing foods with varying moisture content.

Below, you can find the protein, fat, and carbohydrate content for the Trout and Salmon Meal Formula using a dry matter basis:

• Protein 33%
• Fat 16%
• Carbohydrates 43%

Ingredient List

Trout, Salmon Meal, Peas, Chickpeas, Pea Flour, Dehydrated Alfalfa Meal, Natural Flavors, Salmon Oil, Flaxseed, Sunflower Oil (preserved with Citric Acid), Dried Beet Pulp, Calcium Carbonate, Potassium Chloride, Salt, Minerals (Zinc Proteinate, Iron Proteinate, Copper Proteinate, Manganese Proteinate, Cobalt Proteinate), Choline Chloride, Dicalcium Phosphate, Taurine, Vitamins (Vitamin A Acetate, Vitamin D3 Supplement, Vitamin E Supplement, Niacin, d-Calcium Pantothenate, Thiamine Mononitrate, Pyridoxine Hydrochloride, Riboflavin, Folic Acid, Biotin, Vitamin B12 supplement), Blueberries, Carrots, Cranberries, Lactic Acid, Calcium Iodate, Sodium Selenite. Preserved with Mixed Tocopherols.

Zignature Recipes

Zignatures kibble-based product line includes 13 different formulas, each of which is based on a different protein (or combination of proteins). Some of the proteins included in these recipes are pretty common ingredients used in dog foods, while others are based around exotic proteins, which arent often included in many other commercial foods.

Each of these recipes are otherwise pretty similar, as theyre all comprised of similar carbohydrates and fats. Accordingly, youll want to focus on the primary protein when picking a recipe for your pup.

• Pork
• Goat
• Venison
• Lamb
• Kangaroo
• Turkey
• Guinea Fowl
• Duck
• Salmon
• Whitefish
• Trout & Salmon Meal
• Catfish
• Zssential

Special Notes

Dog Food Advisor examined and rated seven of the formulas in Zignatures dry food product line. Four of the products (Duck, Lamb, Venison, and Kangaroo) received 4-star ratings, while three of the products (Pork, Catfish, and Zssential) received 5-star ratings.

The primary difference between those products that received a 4-star rating and those that received a 5-star rating appears to be the protein content.

Most of the products that earned 5 stars from Dog Food Advisor have a 30% or higher protein content (based on Guaranteed Analysis), while those that earned 4 stars had protein contents of about 26%.

However, it is important to note that all of the Zignature dry foods have protein levels that exceed the AAFCO recommendations for adults (18%) and puppies (22%).

Our Top Zignature Dry Picks

When it comes to our top picks for Zignature Dry (Kibble) we recommend these recipes, which each received 5-star ratings through Dog Food Advisor and boast 30% or higher protein content:

You can find the full selection of Zignture dry kibble on Chewy.com and get 30% off your first order!

Formula #2: Zignature Canned Foods

Our Rating:

Zignature also produces a very impressive line of canned foods.

By and large, their canned foods are made according to the same basic template as their dry foods. Consequently, theyre of similar quality, and they appear to be equally tasty to dogs (in fact, most dogs probably prefer the canned versions).

Well examine Zignatures Lamb (Canned) Formula in greater detail below.

Percentages

The Guaranteed Analysis for Zignatures Lamb Formula is as follows:

• Protein 8%
• Fat 4.5%
• Carbohydrate Not Provided

While the guaranteed analysis for any food provides helpful information, it is important to compare the nutritional content of different foods using a dry matter basis (especially when comparing wet foods with dry foods).

Below, you can find the protein, fat, and carbohydrate content for the canned Lamb Formula using a dry matter basis:

• Protein 43%
• Fat 25%
• Carbohydrates 24%

At an impressive 43% dry matter protein analysis, Zignatures canned foods pack a protein punch!

Ingredient List

Lamb, Lamb Broth, Lamb Liver, Peas, Carrots, Chickpeas, Lamb Meal, Calcium Carbonate, Agar-Agar, Calcium Carbonate, Choline Chloride, Salt, Sun-cured Alfalfa Meal, Potassium Chloride, Dicalcium Phosphate, Cranberries, Blueberries, Minerals (Zinc Proteinate, Iron Proteinate, Copper Proteinate, Manganese Proteinate, Sodium Selenite, Calcium Iodate), Vitamins (Vitamin E Supplement, Thiamine Mononitrate, Niacin Supplement, Calcium Pantothenate, Biotin, Vitamin A Supplement, Riboflavin Supplement, Vitamin B12 Supplement, Pyridoxine Hydrochloride, Vitamin D3 Supplement, Folic Acid)

Zignature Recipes

Like their dry food formulas, most of the canned formulas produced by Zignature contain a few primary proteins (typically derived from the same animal), while the carbohydrate content is provided by low-glycemic vegetables.

However, they also offer one formula Zssentials that contains a variety of different protein sources.

Also like the dry formulas, all of the canned formulas in Zignatures product line contain a few antioxidant-rich fruits, such as blueberries or cranberries. Moreover, theyre made without grains, potatoes or chicken-based products.

• Pork
• Goat
• Venison
• Lamb
• Kangaroo
• Turkey
• Guinea Fowl
• Duck
• Salmon
• Whitefish
• Trout & Salmon Meal
• Catfish
• Zssential

Special Notes

Oddly, Dog Food Advisor gives Zignatures entire canned product line a 5-star rating, but each individual recipe receives only a 4- or 4.5-star rating.

Nevertheless, as with the dry foods produced by Zignature, the primary difference between the 4- and 4.5-star products relates to protein content.

Those in the former category have 8% protein content (guaranteed analysis), while those in the latter have 9% protein content.

Our Top ZignatureCanned / Wet Picks

When it comes to our top picks for Zignature Canned / Wet formulas we recommend these recipes, which each received 4.5 stars from Dog Food Advisor

You can find the full selection of Zignture wet canned foods on Chewy.com and get 30% off your first order!

Pros: What Does Zignature Do Right?

Zignatures 26 formulas are easily some of the best foods available to dog owners. Lets talk about some of the pros of Zignature.

+ High Quality Protein As #1 Ingredient

Each formula features a premium whole protein at the top of the ingredient list, and a handful of Zignature formulas feature two or more. And while Zignature uses a number of relatively standard whole proteins, such as pork, duck, and turkey, they also produce foods containing goat, guinea fowl, and other exotic proteins.

These proteins are often helpful for dogs battling food allergies. In fact, all of Zignatures foods are made without the most common canine allergens, such as corn, wheat, soy, dairy, or chicken-based products (eggs, chicken meal, etc.).

+ All Formulas Are Limited Ingredient

Given that Zignatures formulas are all limited-ingredient recipes, made without the most common allergic triggers, and available with several different exotic proteins, they are fantastic for dogs with food allergies.

Limited ingredient formulas basically refer to foods where the manufacturer avoids adding fillers or mystery ingredients, keeping ingredient lists as short as possible.

Limited ingredient formulas are often better to use for dogs with allergies because it can be easier to detect which foods are causing a problem (as opposed to a formula that includes chicken, beef, grains, eggs, and cheese, in which case it would be difficult to determine which ingredient is problematic).

+ High-Quality Secondary Proteins

Zignatures formulas also provide high-quality secondary proteins in the form of a meat meal (made from the same species as one of the primary proteins). And while meat meals may not sound appetizing to people, theyre incredibly nutritious (they provide more protein per ounce than whole proteins do) and dogs typically find meat meals to be delicious.

+ Grain-Free Carbohydrates

The carbohydrates used in Zignatures formulas are also very impressive. None of the products include grains, nor do they use potatoes. Instead, they rely on things like peas, chickpeas, and lentils to provide the carbohydrate content for the food.

+ Omega-3 Fatty Acids

Each Zignature recipe includes one or more ingredients that are rich in omega-3 fatty acids, such as sunflower oil, salmon, salmon meal, or flaxseed. Omega-3 fatty acids help to fight inflammation and promote proper skin, coat, and joint health, among other things.

Each recipe exceeds the AAFCO requirements for all life stages, so you can use these formulas for puppies, adults, and pregnant or lactating females. They are all made in the USA from ingredients sourced from reliably safe locations, including Australia, New Zealand, and France.

Nutrition, quality, and food-safety aside, most Zignature recipes seem to be very palatable to dogs.

Cons: What CouldZignature Do Better?

There are three or four minor issues with Zignature foods, but we wouldnt consider any of them to be deal breakers. Nevertheless, it is important to consider the good and the bad when picking a food for your four-footer.

Fairly New Company

One of the first things some owners may find troubling is that Pets Global Inc. is a relatively new company. However, they certainly arent a brand-new startup, and theyve proven to be impressive over the eight years theyve been in business. Additionally, theyve never been forced to initiate a recall in this time.

No Recipes With Chicken

Some owners may note that chicken is conspicuously absent from all Zignature products. None of the recipes utilize chicken as the whole protein, nor do any use chicken meal as the secondary protein. This isnt necessarily a drawback, and many owners will actually consider this a positive characteristic, but some dogs like chicken more than any other protein.

Not Fortified With Probiotics

Additionally, Zignature products are not fortified with any probiotics (beneficial bacteria that help promote proper digestion), which is slightly disappointing. However, there are a number of standalone canine probiotic supplements on the market, which you could use if you like.

Expensive Price Point

However, the single biggest drawback to Zignature foods is simple: Theyre quite pricey even by premium dog food standards. A high price tag is to be expected of most high-quality dog foods, and it is all but guaranteed for those that are also grain-free, given that chickpeas, lentils, and peas are more expensive than grains like corn and wheat.

Final Thoughts on Zignature

Zignature dog foods are quite impressive and deserve serious consideration from all owners. They have all of the important features most owners will want in a dog food, including premium proteins and high-value carbohydrates.

Theyre probably best suited for owners who are looking for grain-free options, as well as those with dogs who suffer from food allergies and require a limited-ingredient diet. And, because they are rich in protein and feature only low glycemic vegetables, they may be a good option for diabetic dogs (just be sure to solicit your vets advice first).

Zignature foods arent cheap, so they arent a viable option for budget-limited owners, but the canned products may make good (and somewhat affordable) toppers in some cases.

Have you fed your dog Zignature? What does your dog think of this brand? Share your impressions in the comments!